How important are loud engines?

Column: How important are loud engines?

Published on 04 Mar 2017 14:29

By: Fergal Walsh

Formula One is hitting a new era this year, and while it may not bring the 'angry buzzing of a bee' sound back, the cars will be much quicker, and drivers will be tested. Overtaking ability is yet to evaluated, so it would be unfair to comment on that for now.

If there's one thing I always notice, it's that on all the old online F1 videos that have slipped through the Formula One Group's tight, menacing grasp, fans are displeased with the current Formula.

The most recurring comment I see goes something like: "The good old sounds of F1" or "This is what a real F1 car sounds like". And it's got me pondering, how crucial are these current aesthetics of F1?

Well in my controversial opinion, not very. Fans and drivers alike have made no attempt to hide their feelings on the current engine spec, and the 2017 regulations may just be a distraction to the upset cries of F1 fans. While it is an attempt to make the front of the field competitive again, why have team leaders been saying that they want the cars to look and sound better?

"I would prefer to go back to a normally-aspirated, screaming V10 engine," were the words of Red Bull team boss Christian Horner.

F1 should never ban the idea of moving towards improving the show, as that is what is really missing from the sport. Let me ask you: If we got the loud, screeching V10's back, but the spectacle remained the same as today, would that please the fans?

Are current F1 fans still longing the V10's in a depressing divorce like manner? Can't we have this deep, rumbling engine and still have a good viewing? I hope so, and I'm really interested to see how Liberty Media react to this outburst that has been going on since 2014.

If there's a man with a plan, it's Ross Brawn, but I just fear that F1 feels it needs to move backwards to move forwards. Evolve with what we have, don't abandon and start from scratch. THAT is not what F1 is about, not engines that don't tear at your eardrums.

Fergal Walsh

f1fan0101

Posts: 1,804

Interesting.. I just want some good on track action, then I'm happy

1
Mar 4 2017 - 16:22

F1 News

Replies (5)

f1fan0101

Posts: 1,804
Interesting.. I just want some good on track action, then I'm happy
- + 1
- Mar 4 2017 - 16:22
calle.itw

Posts: 8,527
Interesting article, and I agree with the author's opinion. I dont know why people still complain, this year's cars sound great in this video.
- + 0
- Mar 4 2017 - 16:30
MADMICK

Posts: 19
If Ross were to ask most fans which they prefer :-
1)A procession of screaming V10s who rarely change position whilst leaving you deaf for 3 days after a race
OR
2) closely matched position swapping cars that are so fast they make you wonder how they stay on track and which are loud but not ear damaging.

I know which I prefer.
- + 0
- Mar 4 2017 - 18:43
Barron

Posts: 625
I may be missing something here but the engines in the above clip appear to be revving way above the 10k or thereabouts of last year. Indeed i would go so far as to say 15k +. What is meant by the video title: "V12 V10 & V8 engines?? These do not sound like the V6 hybrids at all. Is someone having a little joke on us?
- + 0
- Mar 5 2017 - 20:40
- LB
  
  Posts: 6
  Yeah, I'd be willing to bet you a pint that somebody's been doing some very clever sound editing on the clip :-P
  + 0
  
  Mar 13 2017 - 10:46

Total queries: 4
Total time: 0.29840898513794
time	sincestart	caller	annotate	bt	desc
	0.000606				instantiate query log (0Q - total module time: 0.00075316s)	""
	0.001367				boot (0Q - total module time: 0.00013804s)	""
	0.001508				translation-init (1Q - total module time: 0.00126696s)	""
0.00036311	0.002399	/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/index.php		/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/vendor/doctrine/dbal/lib/Doctrine/DBAL/Statement.php:189(stopQuery) /var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/Repository/Redirect.php:105(execute) /var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/Entities/Redirect.php:112(findByOrigin) /var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/Services/Redirects.php:108(getRedirectOrFalse) /var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/Router.php:115(checkForDBRedirects) /var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/website.php:260(execute) /var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/index.php:11(require_once)	SELECT redirects.id, redirects.origin, redirects.referer FROM redirects WHERE redirects.origin = :origin ORDER BY id	{"origin":"\/en\/column\/f1\/222934\/how-important-are-loud-engines"}
	0.002780				controller::column/f1/222934/how-important-are-loud-engines (2Q - total module time: 0.21932983s)	""
0.00623894	0.003656	/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/Controllers/News.php		/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/vendor/doctrine/dbal/lib/Doctrine/DBAL/Statement.php:189(stopQuery) /var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/Repository/Article.php:389(execute) /var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/Controllers/News.php:127(findNextArticle) {"function":"F1T\\Controllers\\{closure}","class":"F1T\\Controllers\\News","object":{"current_page":"news"},"type":"->","args":[]} /var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/Services/Cache.php:144(call_user_func) /var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/Controllers/News.php:158(lazyFetch) /var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/Controllers/News.php:47(action_Index) /var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/Router.php:269(dispatch) /var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/Router.php:195(_load) /var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/website.php:260(execute) /var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/index.php:11(require_once)	SELECT Articles.ArticleId AS ArticleId, Articles.RewriteUrl AS RewriteUrl, Articles.ArticleType as ArticleType, Articles.Category as Category, Articles.cntnlang AS cntnlang, RacingSeries.RewriteUrl AS RacingSeriesRewriteUrl FROM Articles INNER JOIN RacingSeries ON Articles.RacingSerieId = RacingSeries.RacingSerieId WHERE Articles.cntnlang = :siteLang AND Articles.SiteId = :siteId AND Articles.Activated = 1 AND Articles.PublishDate < :publishDate AND Articles.ArticleType IN (:param0, :param1, :param2) AND Articles.ArticleId > :articleId ORDER BY Articles.ArticleId ASC LIMIT 1	{"siteLang":"en","siteId":"1","publishDate":"2025-12-12 16:50:00","articleId":222934,":param0":"Nieuws",":param1":"LiveRaceReport",":param2":"Liveblog"}
0.13603497	0.009933	/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/Controllers/News.php		/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/vendor/doctrine/dbal/lib/Doctrine/DBAL/Statement.php:189(stopQuery) /var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/Repository/Article.php:318(execute) /var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/Controllers/News.php:128(findPrevArticle) {"function":"F1T\\Controllers\\{closure}","class":"F1T\\Controllers\\News","object":{"current_page":"news"},"type":"->","args":[]} /var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/Services/Cache.php:144(call_user_func) /var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/Controllers/News.php:158(lazyFetch) /var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/Controllers/News.php:47(action_Index) /var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/Router.php:269(dispatch) /var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/Router.php:195(_load) /var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/website.php:260(execute) /var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/index.php:11(require_once)	SELECT Articles.ArticleId AS ArticleId, Articles.RewriteUrl AS RewriteUrl, Articles.ArticleType as ArticleType, Articles.Category as Category, Articles.cntnlang AS cntnlang, RacingSeries.RewriteUrl AS RacingSeriesRewriteUrl FROM Articles INNER JOIN RacingSeries ON Articles.RacingSerieId = RacingSeries.RacingSerieId WHERE Articles.cntnlang = :siteLang AND Articles.SiteId = :siteId AND Articles.Activated = 1 AND Articles.PublishDate < :publishDate AND Articles.ArticleType IN (:param0, :param1, :param2) AND Articles.ArticleId < :articleId ORDER BY Articles.ArticleId DESC LIMIT 1	{"siteLang":"en","siteId":"1","publishDate":"2025-12-12 16:50:00","articleId":222934,":param0":"Nieuws",":param1":"LiveRaceReport",":param2":"Liveblog"}
	0.222117		cacheAble: yes		module:News\Result (0Q - total module time: 0.00046897s)	""
	0.222590		cacheAble: yes		module:News\Photos (0Q - total module time: 0.00010490s)	""
	0.222698		cacheAble: yes		module:News\Trending (0Q - total module time: 0.00014305s)	""
	0.222843		cacheAble: yes		module:News\Reply (1Q - total module time: 0.07193279s)	""
0.05774403	0.223363	/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/Repository/CommentVotes.php		/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/vendor/doctrine/dbal/lib/Doctrine/DBAL/Connection.php:1323(stopQuery) /var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/vendor/doctrine/orm/lib/Doctrine/ORM/Query/Exec/SingleSelectExecutor.php:31(executeQuery) /var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/vendor/doctrine/orm/lib/Doctrine/ORM/Query.php:325(execute) /var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/vendor/doctrine/orm/lib/Doctrine/ORM/AbstractQuery.php:1212(_doExecute) /var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/vendor/doctrine/orm/lib/Doctrine/ORM/AbstractQuery.php:1166(executeIgnoreQueryCache) /var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/vendor/doctrine/orm/lib/Doctrine/ORM/AbstractQuery.php:901(execute) /var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/Repository/CommentVotes.php:192(getResult) /var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/Services/CommentVotesManager.php:46(getCommentVotesByVoteIp) /var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/Modules/News/Reply.php:101(getCommentVotesByIP) /var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/ModuleBase.php:115(internalRender) /var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/ModuleBase.php:89(captureOutput) {"function":"F1T\\{closure}","class":"F1T\\ModuleBase","object":{"_amp":false},"type":"->","args":[]} /var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/Services/Cache.php:144(call_user_func) /var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/ModuleBase.php:92(lazyFetch) /var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/Services/ViewRenderer/TwigExtensions/ModuleRenderer.php:35(fetch) /var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/vendor/twig/twig/src/Environment.php(418) : eval()'d code:549(renderModule) /var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/vendor/twig/twig/src/Template.php:182(block_mainContent) /var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/vendor/twig/twig/src/Environment.php(418) : eval()'d code:62(displayBlock) /var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/vendor/twig/twig/src/Template.php:182(block_content) /var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/vendor/twig/twig/src/Environment.php(418) : eval()'d code:715(displayBlock) /var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/vendor/twig/twig/src/Template.php:405(doDisplay) /var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/vendor/twig/twig/src/Template.php:378(displayWithErrorHandling) /var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/vendor/twig/twig/src/Environment.php(418) : eval()'d code:45(display) /var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/vendor/twig/twig/src/Template.php:405(doDisplay) /var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/vendor/twig/twig/src/Template.php:378(displayWithErrorHandling) /var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/vendor/twig/twig/src/Environment.php(418) : eval()'d code:46(display) /var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/vendor/twig/twig/src/Template.php:405(doDisplay) /var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/vendor/twig/twig/src/Template.php:378(displayWithErrorHandling) /var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/vendor/twig/twig/src/Template.php:390(display) /var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/vendor/twig/twig/src/TemplateWrapper.php:45(render) /var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/vendor/twig/twig/src/Environment.php:318(render) /var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/Services/ViewRenderer/TwigRenderer.php:115(render) /var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/ViewTrait.php:98(render) /var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/ViewTrait.php:79(renderViewFile) /var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/website.php:261(render) /var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/index.php:11(require_once)	SELECT c0_.CommentId AS CommentId_0, c1_.Vote AS Vote_1 FROM Comments c0_ INNER JOIN CommentVotes c1_ ON (c1_.CommentId = c0_.CommentId) WHERE c0_.ArticleId = ? AND c1_.VoteIp = ?	[222934,"216.73.216.191"]
	0.294780		cacheAble: no		module:Sidebar (0Q - total module time: 0.00039816s)	""
	0.295180				sidebar:sidebar-news-read::ads (0Q - total module time: 0.00001407s)	""
	0.295196				sidebar:sidebar-news-read::gpschedule (0Q - total module time: 0.00000191s)	""
	0.295199		cacheAble: yes		module:GpSchedule (0Q - total module time: 0.00026202s)	""
	0.295463				sidebar:sidebar-news-read::results (0Q - total module time: 0.00000405s)	""
	0.295468		cacheAble: yes		module:Results (0Q - total module time: 0.00009990s)	""
	0.295570				sidebar:sidebar-news-read::testcalendar (0Q - total module time: 0.00000191s)	""
	0.295574		cacheAble: yes		module:TestCalendar (0Q - total module time: 0.00009298s)	""
	0.295669				sidebar:sidebar-news-read::ads (0Q - total module time: 0.00000405s)	""
	0.295674				sidebar:sidebar-news-read::ads (0Q - total module time: 0.00000095s)	""
	0.295676				sidebar:sidebar-news-read::relatednews (0Q - total module time: 0.00000215s)	""
	0.295679		cacheAble: yes		module:RelatedNews (0Q - total module time: 0.00005698s)	""
	0.295738				sidebar:sidebar-news-read::whoischatting (0Q - total module time: 0.00000405s)	""
	0.295742				sidebar:sidebar-news-read::ads (0Q - total module time: 0.00000215s)	""
	0.295745				sidebar:sidebar-news-read::poll (0Q - total module time: 0.00000191s)	""
	0.295747		cacheAble: no		module:Poll (0Q - total module time: 0.00163412s)	""
	0.297383				sidebar:sidebar-news-read::ads (0Q - total module time: 0.00000501s)	""
	0.297389				sidebar:sidebar-news-read::ads (0Q - total module time: 0.00000095s)	""
	0.297391				sidebar:sidebar-news-read::gpcalendar (0Q - total module time: 0.00000191s)	""
	0.297393		cacheAble: yes		module:GpCalendar (0Q - total module time: 0.00010705s)	""
	0.297503				sidebar:sidebar-news-read::driver_Info (0Q - total module time: 0.00000286s)	""
	0.297508		cacheAble: no		module:Driver\Info (0Q - total module time: 0.00001597s)	""
	0.297525				sidebar:sidebar-news-read::team_Info (0Q - total module time: 0.00000286s)	""
	0.297528		cacheAble: no		module:Team\Info (0Q - total module time: 0.00000906s)	""
	0.297538				sidebar:sidebar-news-read::linkedKeywords (0Q - total module time: 0.00000215s)	""
	0.297540				sidebar:sidebar-news-read::gpsidebarnavigation (0Q - total module time: 0.00000191s)	""
	0.297542		cacheAble: no		module:GpSidebarNavigation (0Q - total module time: 0.00034904s)	""
	0.297893		cacheAble: yes		module:Layout\Footer (0Q - total module time: 0.00009704s)	""
	0.297992		cacheAble: yes		module:News\Breaking (0Q - total module time: 0.00041199s)	""
	0.298407				done	""

Column: How important are loud engines?

f1fan0101

Trending news

Replies (5)

f1fan0101

calle.itw

MADMICK

Barron

LB

Grand Prix of Belgium

Friday

Saturday

Sunday

Race / Startgrid

Grand Prix of Belgium

Friday

Saturday

Sunday

Friday

Saturday

Sunday

World Championship standings 2023

Test calendar

Related news

test 2

Can Racing Go Mainstream In The US?

LIVE Updates: Follow the third day of the F1 Pre-season test in Bahrain

LIVE Updates: Follow the second day of the F1 Pre-season test in Bahrain

Give your opinion!

Will Bottas challenge Hamilton for the world championship in 2020?

Formula 1 Calendar - 2024

Formula 1 Calendar - 2024