Brawn: Nothing sinister behind decision to penalise Vettel

  • Published on 11 Jun 2019 18:27
  • comments 8
  • By: Fergal Walsh

There was nothing sinister behind the stewards' decision to penalise Sebastian Vettel during the Canadian Grand Prix, according to Ross Brawn.

Formula 1's managing director spoke about the controversial decision that denied Ferrari and Sebastian Vettel their first win of the season in Montreal after it was deemed Vettel rejoined the track unsafely. 

"I can understand the disappointment and frustration Vettel felt (and that he is surely still feeling), as he feels he was robbed of a deserved win," Brawn wrote in his post-race debrief. 

"The most important thing from the weekend, though, is that the fans saw a vintage Vettel performance, which has perhaps been absent since last year’s Belgian Grand Prix."

Brawn suggested that it would be a good idea for the FIA to provide fans with insight as to why certain decisions are made.

"I have a lot of respect for the work of the stewards and for their professionalism and I believe they would be the first to say that they would prefer not to see a race outcome decided via a penalty," he said.

"At the same time, I understand how difficult it must be for fans to understand why the driver on the top step of the podium is not the one who crossed the finish line first.

"That’s why transparency is important when it comes to explaining the decisions of the stewards, especially in such a complex sport as Formula 1.

"It is in football, where despite the arrival of VAR, there is still discussion as to whether a handball should be punished with a penalty or not.

"Therefore, it might be useful to work with the FIA on solutions that would allow the stewards to explain their decisions to the fans and to elaborate on how they reached them."

But Brawn says that there was nothing controversial behind the decision to hand Vettel a penalty, with the Briton sanctioning that no steward has a hidden agenda against a particular driver or team.

"Having said that, I would emphatically add is that there is nothing sinister about a decision like this.

"You might agree with it or not, but none of those who take on the role of steward each weekend has a hidden agenda, and fans can be certain of that," Brawn asserted.

boudy

Posts: 1,168

agreed, it was interesting to see. My initial thought was to see the race flow also but than i remember all the penalties other drivers got for similar (or even lesser) issues (Remember when verstappen cut the corner when he lost his brakes an Vettel was following). With that in mind I think the ... [Read more]

  • 1
  • Jun 12 2019 - 07:56

Replies (8)

Login to reply
  • The only reason this was such a big deal was the names involved. This wasn't anywhere near as controversial as they have made it appear. We've definitely seen worse. The other thing that has made this a huge drama was Sebastian's massive overreaction and corresponding antics after the race. Agree with the decision or not, it (1) it wasn't a straightforward decision, and (2) it should have been a straightforward but Seb made another mistake under pressure.

    I also understand the fans frustration, because the rules in theory prevented a battle (although I don't agree with that because Lewis was still trying to overtake on track, probably to make it feel more like a real win). Additionally, I understand Sebastian desperation for a win, and absolute necessity to take the attention away from his mistake and put it all on the stewards.

    • + 0
    • Jun 11 2019 - 21:46
    • Feelings would be different if it was the other way around. if Hamilton was penalised

      • + 0
      • Jun 11 2019 - 22:53
    • I agree with the point about it being treated differently because of the drivers involved. However when a decision involves the championship contenders it’s always going to be in the spotlight.
      As for Vettels overreaction, he’s got form for that. It isn’t that long ago he clashed wheels with Lewis because he thought he brake tested him. Who would have thought a 4 times world champion would be highly strung ?

      • + 0
      • Jun 11 2019 - 23:21
    • @f1fan0101 I opposed the imposition of the penalty, but not because it wasn't against the rules. Rather, because it was marginal and I wanted to see the race flow. It wouldn't be different if it were Hamilton I don't hate the guy. In fact, I opposed the penalty he got in 2008 of 25 seconds. But I get it's difficult for people to think about this without going to the extremes or assuming others are equally polarized

      • + 0
      • Jun 11 2019 - 23:23
  • I fell like this will still be talked about when we get to france

    • + 0
    • Jun 11 2019 - 22:53
    • boudy

      Posts: 1,168

      agreed, it was interesting to see. My initial thought was to see the race flow also but than i remember all the penalties other drivers got for similar (or even lesser) issues (Remember when verstappen cut the corner when he lost his brakes an Vettel was following). With that in mind I think the penalty is just. However would he have gotten the penalty if other drivers were involved. If Vettel came of the gas whilst on the grass he would have lost momentum and come back on the circuit slower giving Hamilton the opportunity to overtake but he didn't and Hamilton had to brake/slow down to not have contact. The fact that Hamilton had to do this was the issue. The rules need to be changed around this issue, but for everyone and not just the top two teams. Stewards did a good job here, but i don't like it.

      • + 1
      • Jun 12 2019 - 07:56
  • Bob60

    Posts: 1

    Should off team told Vettel let Hamilton pass him. As Vettels car fastest on straight and with DRS retake Hamilton. Which would off stoped time penalty and made for more interesting race

    • + 0
    • Jun 13 2019 - 10:33
    • It wouldnt have reset the time penalty. He would have been dropped to third

      • + 0
      • Jun 13 2019 - 21:34

BE Grand Prix of Belgium

Local time 

BEGrand Prix of Belgium

Local time 

World Championship standings 2023

Show full world champion standings

Test calendar

See full test schedule

Related news

Give your opinion!

Will Bottas challenge Hamilton for the world championship in 2020?

Formula 1 Calendar - 2024

Date
Grand Prix
Circuit
-
Bahrain
29 - Mar 2 2024
Bahrain
7 - Mar 9 2024
Saudi Arabia
22 - Mar 24 2024
Australia
5 - Apr 7 2024
Japan
19 - Apr 21 2024
China
3 - May 5 2024
United States of America
17 - May 19 2024
Italy
24 - May 26 2024
Monaco
7 - Jun 9 2024
Canada
21 - Jun 23 2024
Spain
28 - Jun 30 2024
Austria
5 - Jul 7 2024
United Kingdom
19 - Jul 21 2024
Hungary
26 - Jul 28 2024
Belgium
23 - Aug 25 2024
Netherlands
30 - Sep 1 2024
Italy
13 - Sep 15 2024
Azerbaijan
20 - Sep 22 2024
Singapore
18 - Oct 20 2024
United States of America
25 - Oct 27 2024
Mexico
1 - Nov 3 2024
Brazil
22 - Nov 24 2024
United States of America
29 - Dec 1 2024
Qatar
6 - Dec 8 2024
United Arab Emirates
See full schedule

Formula 1 Calendar - 2024

Date
Grand Prix & Circuit
29 - Mar 2 2024
7 - Mar 9 2024
Saudi Arabia Jeddah Street Circuit
22 - Mar 24 2024
Australia Albert Park
5 - Apr 7 2024
19 - Apr 21 2024
3 - May 5 2024
United States of America Miami International Autodrome
17 - May 19 2024
24 - May 26 2024
Monaco Monte Carlo
7 - Jun 9 2024
21 - Jun 23 2024
28 - Jun 30 2024
Austria Red Bull Ring
5 - Jul 7 2024
United Kingdom Silverstone
19 - Jul 21 2024
Hungary Hungaroring
26 - Jul 28 2024
23 - Aug 25 2024
Netherlands Circuit Zandvoort
30 - Sep 1 2024
Italy Monza
13 - Sep 15 2024
Azerbaijan Baku City Circuit
20 - Sep 22 2024
18 - Oct 20 2024
United States of America Circuit of the Americas
25 - Oct 27 2024
1 - Nov 3 2024
Brazil Interlagos
22 - Nov 24 2024
United States of America Las Vegas Street Circuit
29 - Dec 1 2024
6 - Dec 8 2024
United Arab Emirates Yas Marina Circuit
See full schedule

Driver profile

  • Country Germany
  • Date of b. Jul 3 1987 (38)
  • Place of b. Heppenheim, Germany
  • Weight 62 kg
  • Length 1.75 m
Show full profile

Team profile

Show full profile
show sidebar

Total queries: 4
Total time: 0.17507100105286
timesincestartcallerannotatebtdesc
0.000448
instantiate query log (0Q - total module time: 0.00058007s)
""
0.001033
boot (0Q - total module time: 0.00010085s)
""
0.001137
translation-init (1Q - total module time: 0.00110197s)
""
0.000283960.001943/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/index.php/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/vendor/doctrine/dbal/lib/Doctrine/DBAL/Statement.php:189(stopQuery)
/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/Repository/Redirect.php:105(execute)
/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/Entities/Redirect.php:112(findByOrigin)
/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/Services/Redirects.php:108(getRedirectOrFalse)
/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/Router.php:115(checkForDBRedirects)
/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/website.php:260(execute)
/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/index.php:11(require_once)
SELECT redirects.id, redirects.origin, redirects.referer FROM redirects WHERE redirects.origin = :origin ORDER BY id
{"origin":"\/en\/news\/f1\/248339\/brawn-nothing-sinister-behind-decision-to-penalise-vettel"}
0.002241
controller::news/f1/248339/brawn-nothing-sinister-behind-decision-to-penalise-vettel (2Q - total module time: 0.10216999s)
""
0.000494000.004580/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/Controllers/News.php/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/vendor/doctrine/dbal/lib/Doctrine/DBAL/Statement.php:189(stopQuery)
/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/Repository/Article.php:389(execute)
/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/Controllers/News.php:127(findNextArticle)
{"function":"F1T\\Controllers\\{closure}","class":"F1T\\Controllers\\News","object":{"current_page":"news"},"type":"->","args":[]}
/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/Services/Cache.php:144(call_user_func)
/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/Controllers/News.php:158(lazyFetch)
/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/Controllers/News.php:47(action_Index)
/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/Router.php:269(dispatch)
/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/Router.php:195(_load)
/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/website.php:260(execute)
/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/index.php:11(require_once)
SELECT Articles.ArticleId AS ArticleId, Articles.RewriteUrl AS RewriteUrl, Articles.ArticleType as ArticleType, Articles.Category as Category, Articles.cntnlang AS cntnlang, RacingSeries.RewriteUrl AS RacingSeriesRewriteUrl FROM Articles INNER JOIN RacingSeries ON Articles.RacingSerieId = RacingSeries.RacingSerieId WHERE Articles.cntnlang = :siteLang AND Articles.SiteId = :siteId AND Articles.Activated = 1 AND Articles.PublishDate < :publishDate AND Articles.ArticleType IN (:param0, :param1, :param2) AND Articles.ArticleId > :articleId ORDER BY Articles.ArticleId ASC LIMIT 1
{"siteLang":"en","siteId":"1","publishDate":"2026-02-04 09:50:00","articleId":248339,":param0":"Nieuws",":param1":"LiveRaceReport",":param2":"Liveblog"}
0.052344800.005100/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/Controllers/News.php/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/vendor/doctrine/dbal/lib/Doctrine/DBAL/Statement.php:189(stopQuery)
/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/Repository/Article.php:318(execute)
/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/Controllers/News.php:128(findPrevArticle)
{"function":"F1T\\Controllers\\{closure}","class":"F1T\\Controllers\\News","object":{"current_page":"news"},"type":"->","args":[]}
/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/Services/Cache.php:144(call_user_func)
/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/Controllers/News.php:158(lazyFetch)
/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/Controllers/News.php:47(action_Index)
/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/Router.php:269(dispatch)
/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/Router.php:195(_load)
/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/website.php:260(execute)
/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/index.php:11(require_once)
SELECT Articles.ArticleId AS ArticleId, Articles.RewriteUrl AS RewriteUrl, Articles.ArticleType as ArticleType, Articles.Category as Category, Articles.cntnlang AS cntnlang, RacingSeries.RewriteUrl AS RacingSeriesRewriteUrl FROM Articles INNER JOIN RacingSeries ON Articles.RacingSerieId = RacingSeries.RacingSerieId WHERE Articles.cntnlang = :siteLang AND Articles.SiteId = :siteId AND Articles.Activated = 1 AND Articles.PublishDate < :publishDate AND Articles.ArticleType IN (:param0, :param1, :param2) AND Articles.ArticleId < :articleId ORDER BY Articles.ArticleId DESC LIMIT 1
{"siteLang":"en","siteId":"1","publishDate":"2026-02-04 09:50:00","articleId":248339,":param0":"Nieuws",":param1":"LiveRaceReport",":param2":"Liveblog"}
0.104418 cacheAble: yes
module:News\Result (0Q - total module time: 0.00054598s)
""
0.104966 cacheAble: yes
module:News\Photos (0Q - total module time: 0.00013208s)
""
0.105102 cacheAble: yes
module:News\Trending (0Q - total module time: 0.00011802s)
""
0.105223 cacheAble: yes
module:News\Reply (1Q - total module time: 0.06122088s)
""
0.050781010.105884/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/Repository/CommentVotes.php/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/vendor/doctrine/dbal/lib/Doctrine/DBAL/Connection.php:1323(stopQuery)
/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/vendor/doctrine/orm/lib/Doctrine/ORM/Query/Exec/SingleSelectExecutor.php:31(executeQuery)
/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/vendor/doctrine/orm/lib/Doctrine/ORM/Query.php:325(execute)
/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/vendor/doctrine/orm/lib/Doctrine/ORM/AbstractQuery.php:1212(_doExecute)
/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/vendor/doctrine/orm/lib/Doctrine/ORM/AbstractQuery.php:1166(executeIgnoreQueryCache)
/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/vendor/doctrine/orm/lib/Doctrine/ORM/AbstractQuery.php:901(execute)
/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/Repository/CommentVotes.php:192(getResult)
/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/Services/CommentVotesManager.php:46(getCommentVotesByVoteIp)
/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/Modules/News/Reply.php:101(getCommentVotesByIP)
/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/ModuleBase.php:115(internalRender)
/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/ModuleBase.php:89(captureOutput)
{"function":"F1T\\{closure}","class":"F1T\\ModuleBase","object":{"_amp":false},"type":"->","args":[]}
/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/Services/Cache.php:144(call_user_func)
/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/ModuleBase.php:92(lazyFetch)
/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/Services/ViewRenderer/TwigExtensions/ModuleRenderer.php:35(fetch)
/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/vendor/twig/twig/src/Environment.php(418) : eval()'d code:549(renderModule)
/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/vendor/twig/twig/src/Template.php:182(block_mainContent)
/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/vendor/twig/twig/src/Environment.php(418) : eval()'d code:62(displayBlock)
/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/vendor/twig/twig/src/Template.php:182(block_content)
/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/vendor/twig/twig/src/Environment.php(418) : eval()'d code:715(displayBlock)
/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/vendor/twig/twig/src/Template.php:405(doDisplay)
/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/vendor/twig/twig/src/Template.php:378(displayWithErrorHandling)
/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/vendor/twig/twig/src/Environment.php(418) : eval()'d code:45(display)
/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/vendor/twig/twig/src/Template.php:405(doDisplay)
/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/vendor/twig/twig/src/Template.php:378(displayWithErrorHandling)
/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/vendor/twig/twig/src/Environment.php(418) : eval()'d code:46(display)
/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/vendor/twig/twig/src/Template.php:405(doDisplay)
/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/vendor/twig/twig/src/Template.php:378(displayWithErrorHandling)
/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/vendor/twig/twig/src/Template.php:390(display)
/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/vendor/twig/twig/src/TemplateWrapper.php:45(render)
/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/vendor/twig/twig/src/Environment.php:318(render)
/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/Services/ViewRenderer/TwigRenderer.php:115(render)
/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/ViewTrait.php:98(render)
/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/ViewTrait.php:79(renderViewFile)
/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/app/website.php:261(render)
/var/www/dev-priyantha.gptoday.net/public_html/index.php:11(require_once)
SELECT c0_.CommentId AS CommentId_0, c1_.Vote AS Vote_1 FROM Comments c0_ INNER JOIN CommentVotes c1_ ON (c1_.CommentId = c0_.CommentId) WHERE c0_.ArticleId = ? AND c1_.VoteIp = ?
[248339,"216.73.216.130"]
0.166447 cacheAble: no
module:Sidebar (0Q - total module time: 0.00045109s)
""
0.166902
sidebar:sidebar-news-read::ads (0Q - total module time: 0.00001311s)
""
0.166916
sidebar:sidebar-news-read::gpschedule (0Q - total module time: 0.00000215s)
""
0.166919 cacheAble: yes
module:GpSchedule (0Q - total module time: 0.00016785s)
""
0.167089
sidebar:sidebar-news-read::results (0Q - total module time: 0.00000405s)
""
0.167095 cacheAble: yes
module:Results (0Q - total module time: 0.00013399s)
""
0.167231
sidebar:sidebar-news-read::testcalendar (0Q - total module time: 0.00000310s)
""
0.167234 cacheAble: yes
module:TestCalendar (0Q - total module time: 0.00014186s)
""
0.167378
sidebar:sidebar-news-read::ads (0Q - total module time: 0.00000501s)
""
0.167384
sidebar:sidebar-news-read::ads (0Q - total module time: 0.00000191s)
""
0.167387
sidebar:sidebar-news-read::relatednews (0Q - total module time: 0.00000191s)
""
0.167390 cacheAble: yes
module:RelatedNews (0Q - total module time: 0.00014210s)
""
0.167534
sidebar:sidebar-news-read::whoischatting (0Q - total module time: 0.00000405s)
""
0.167540
sidebar:sidebar-news-read::ads (0Q - total module time: 0.00000215s)
""
0.167543
sidebar:sidebar-news-read::poll (0Q - total module time: 0.00000095s)
""
0.167545 cacheAble: no
module:Poll (0Q - total module time: 0.00177503s)
""
0.169322
sidebar:sidebar-news-read::ads (0Q - total module time: 0.00000501s)
""
0.169328
sidebar:sidebar-news-read::ads (0Q - total module time: 0.00000191s)
""
0.169330
sidebar:sidebar-news-read::gpcalendar (0Q - total module time: 0.00000215s)
""
0.169333 cacheAble: yes
module:GpCalendar (0Q - total module time: 0.00220704s)
""
0.171543
sidebar:sidebar-news-read::driver_Info (0Q - total module time: 0.00000811s)
""
0.171553 cacheAble: yes
module:Driver\Info (0Q - total module time: 0.00021195s)
""
0.171767
sidebar:sidebar-news-read::team_Info (0Q - total module time: 0.00000691s)
""
0.171775 cacheAble: yes
module:Team\Info (0Q - total module time: 0.00075006s)
""
0.172528
sidebar:sidebar-news-read::linkedKeywords (0Q - total module time: 0.00002980s)
""
0.172560
sidebar:sidebar-news-read::gpsidebarnavigation (0Q - total module time: 0.00000286s)
""
0.172564 cacheAble: no
module:GpSidebarNavigation (0Q - total module time: 0.00057077s)
""
0.173137 cacheAble: yes
module:Layout\Footer (0Q - total module time: 0.00065494s)
""
0.173796 cacheAble: yes
module:News\Breaking (0Q - total module time: 0.00127006s)
""
0.175069
done
""